Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe: Bold, Savory & Surprisingly Simple

Sharing is caring!

If you’ve ever tried the Buona Beef Tuna Genovese sandwich and dreamed of recreating it at home, you’re in the right kitchen. This Buona Beef Tuna Genovese copycat recipe captures the magic of that savory, creamy, tangy bite with layers of marinated beef, herbed tuna mayo, and crisp greens nestled in fresh bread. In this article, we’ll explore the history of the dish, how it brings together two bold proteins in a harmonious way, and guide you through recreating it for a satisfying lunch. If you love sandwiches that surprise, this one’s ready to earn a spot in your rotation.

Table of Contents

Print

Where It All Began – My Obsession with Tuna Genovese

The first time I tasted magic in a sandwich

I didn’t grow up eating dishes like tuna Genovese. My Midwest childhood was full of classic sandwiches: bologna, peanut butter, the occasional turkey and Swiss. But on a trip to Chicago a few years back, I stopped into Buona for a quick bite and left completely spellbound by their Tuna Genovese sandwich. The moment I bit into that warm roll stacked with thin slices of seasoned roast beef and a silky, lemony tuna spread I was hooked. Something about the pairing felt rebellious and right. It wasn’t fishy or fussy. Just bold, meaty, creamy comfort with Italian flair.

Back in my kitchen in West Lafayette, Indiana, I knew I had to recreate it. I’d made roast beef before. I’d whipped up tuna salad. But this? This was different. This was a copycat mission.

I started tinkering, leaning on inspiration from my favorite cozy lunch recipes like this classic tuna melt sandwich and the hearty brisket sandwich I’d made for a family gathering. Over time, I nailed down the balance olive oil, lemon zest, capers, and garlic in the tuna, paired with warm beef and toasted bread. It became more than a sandwich; it became my go-to when I needed a pick-me-up meal with a little edge.

Why this combo works so well

You’d think beef and tuna might clash, but the Italians knew better. This pairing actually has roots in dishes like vitello tonnato cold sliced veal with tuna sauce which inspired Buona’s version. The creamy tuna sauce contrasts beautifully with savory, juicy beef, much like how a horseradish mayo plays with roast prime rib. The balance of umami and acid makes every bite pop. And when layered with crunchy greens and a crusty roll? Perfection.

Coming up next in Part 2, we’ll break down the components beef, tuna spread, and bread and walk you through building the ultimate Buona Beef Tuna Genovese copycat.

Recreating the Layers of Buona’s Iconic Tuna Genovese

The key ingredients that bring it all together

To master this Buona Beef Tuna Genovese copycat recipe, you need to build from the bottom up literally. The heart of this sandwich is all about balance. You’re not just tossing roast beef and tuna on bread. You’re constructing textures and layers that work in harmony. Let’s start with the tuna spread. Use high-quality oil-packed tuna Italian if you can find it. Mix it with mayo, lemon zest, a squeeze of lemon juice, minced garlic, capers, and just a dash of Dijon mustard. It should be creamy but not sloppy, with pops of acid and briny sharpness that elevate the entire bite.

Next comes the beef. Thin-sliced roast beef, preferably homemade or from your favorite deli, needs to be gently reheated in a savory broth. You want the beef warm and juicy but not dripping. Think of the texture from this pepper lunch recipe it’s about retaining that rich flavor without drowning your bread.

The bread? A must. A crusty Italian roll or ciabatta works best. Toast it lightly to hold up under the weight of the filling, giving you that perfect chew-to-crunch ratio. This is not a soft sandwich. It’s bold, built, and bites back a little.

Assembly: more than just stacking

Once everything is prepped, you’ll want to go in order: warm beef on the bottom to melt slightly into the bread, then a thick layer of that tuna spread over the top bun. Press in a handful of arugula or fresh baby spinach its peppery edge brightens up the richness. When you close that sandwich and cut it in half, you’ll see the beauty: tender beef, creamy tuna, crisp greens, and a golden toasted shell. You’re ready to serve a lunch that rivals any deli counter.

Want to pair it with a cozy side? Try this crack chicken noodle soup or a few cheesy sauerkraut bites for a full-bodied lunch spread.

Tips, Tricks, and Regional Twists on Tuna Genovese

What makes this sandwich truly Genovese?

Genovese-style dishes often lean into slow-cooked onions, aromatic herbs, and a blend of rich and light textures. While the Buona Beef Tuna Genovese sandwich isn’t a traditional Ligurian recipe, it’s inspired by classics likevitello tonnato a Northern Italian dish that pairs cold sliced veal with a creamy tuna-caper sauce. This combo of land and sea may sound unusual, but in Italy, it’s a celebration of depth.

In this sandwich, that tradition shows up as seasoned roast beef and an herb-bright tuna spread, layered for contrast. The beef offers savory warmth, while the tuna rich with olive oil and lemon cuts through with brightness. It’s like the best parts of a creamy mushroom pasta paired with the zing of a zesty chicken Caesar wrap: hearty, but fresh.

How to elevate your copycat at home

Let’s talk enhancements. Want to make this sandwich unforgettable? Start with homemade mayo. A simple blend of egg yolk, oil, lemon juice, and mustard gives you silky texture and unbeatable flavor. Add a pinch of anchovy paste to your tuna mix if you like extra umami (don’t worry, it won’t taste fishy). For heat, a little Calabrian chili paste stirred into the tuna or brushed onto the bread adds kick without overpowering.

Fresh herbs matter, too. Toss in chopped parsley or basil into the tuna for an added layer of flavor. And if you’re feeling adventurous, top it with a paper-thin slice of provolone and melt it gently just until gooey.

This sandwich also makes a beautiful open-faced option if you’re serving guests. Toast thick slices of rustic sourdough, layer on the beef and tuna, and garnish with microgreens or caperberries for an appetizer-style presentation.

If you like layered lunches with unexpected pairings, check out this creamy rigatoni pasta bake that mixes rich cheese and savory meat like a dream.

FAQs, Serving Tips & My Final Take on Tuna Genovese

View all

What is tuna Genovese?

Tuna Genovese isn’t a rigid recipe but a style rooted in Italian tradition. It usually refers to a creamy tuna spread made with oil-packed tuna, capers, lemon, and often anchovy or garlic. Inspired by vitello tonnato, this flavor-packed sauce was historically served over veal but later adapted into modern dishes like sandwiches and wraps. It’s rich, savory, tangy and perfect with beef.

What is the Italian dish beef and tuna?

You’re likely thinking of vitello tonnato, a chilled dish of thin-sliced roast veal with a silky tuna-caper sauce. The Buona Beef Tuna Genovese copycat recipe is the lunch-friendly, hand-held version of this combo, swapping veal for beef and serving it warm.

What kind of tuna is used in tuna Genovese?

Always go with high-quality oil-packed tuna ideally Italian or Spanish. Look for tuna packed in olive oil rather than water for maximum flavor and richness. It breaks down easily into a creamy spread and adds depth that water-packed versions just can’t match.

What does tuna Genovese taste like?

It’s creamy, briny, lemony, and lightly herbal with a hint of umami. When paired with beef, the contrast is unforgettable bold yet balanced. It’s not “fishy” at all, but rather smooth, salty, and satisfying.

Serving Ideas & Final Thoughts
Once you’ve stacked your sandwich with warm beef, creamy tuna, and crisp greens, all that’s left is deciding how to serve it. I love plating mine with kettle chips and a cold fizzy lemonade for a summer lunch. If you’re feeling fancy, try a small bowl of this crack chicken noodle soup on the side or even bite-sized cheesy sauerkraut appetizers for a flavor-packed meal.

This sandwich reminds me why I cook because blending bold, unexpected ingredients can feel like a little adventure. The Buona Beef Tuna Genovese is the kind of dish that sounds strange, tastes amazing, and leaves you thinking about the next time you’ll make it.

More recipes? Follow me:
Facebook – Tasty Trails on Facebook
Pinterest – Tasty Trails on Pinterest