Sourdough Pop Tarts Recipe

Sharing is caring!

Let’s be honest: we all grew up on store-bought Pop-Tarts. But once you try this sourdough pop tarts recipe, you’ll never go back. These flaky, buttery breakfast pastries are naturally leavened with sourdough discard, giving them a tender bite and subtle tang that pairs beautifully with jammy fillings. Whether you love fruity flavors or brown sugar cinnamon, these pop tarts are made with real ingredients and no artificial shortcuts. They freeze well, toast beautifully, and best of all, use up that discard sitting in your fridge. Ready to upgrade your mornings with sourdough magic? Let’s bake.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Print

Where Sourdough Meets Pop Tart Nostalgia

Why sourdough discard makes perfect pastry

You might not expect sourdough discard to work in something like a Pop-Tart, but here’s the secret: it gives the dough structure, flavor, and a buttery snap. Unlike regular pie crust, sourdough discard dough has more body. It’s easier to roll and cut, but still melts in your mouth once baked. The discard also adds that signature fermented depth, which is perfect with sweet fillings. When I first used it for sourdough discard cinnamon roll bites, I realized it’s the missing link in most homemade pastries.

You don’t need to wait for your starter to peak just pull discard straight from the fridge. Even slightly sour discard works well, because the fat in the dough balances it beautifully. This is the same base I use for my sourdough discard raspberry cream cheese danishes, and the results are flaky, rich, and golden.

Homemade Pop-Tarts, elevated with flavor

Let’s be clear: these aren’t Pop-Tarts from a box. They’re crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, and made to be devoured fresh or toasted. You can fill them with classic strawberry jam, brown sugar and cinnamon, or lemon curd. I even made a batch with fig jam from our local farmers market, and the flavor was unforgettable.

The real charm is how well sourdough works in pastry. You get the flake without laminating, the flavor without additives, and the bonus of using your discard. It’s a win-win. I’ve even layered this dough in hand pies and croissant-style sourdough pastries for an extra challenge.

How to Shape, Fill, and Bake Sourdough Pop Tarts

Shaping the perfect homemade Pop Tart

Sourdough discard dough becomes much easier to handle after a rest in the fridge. Once chilled, roll it out on a lightly floured surface to about one-eighth inch thick. Use a knife or pastry wheel to trim the dough into clean rectangles, around three by four inches each. This size creates a satisfying bite without being overwhelming. Each Pop Tart will need a top and bottom, so be sure to cut pairs.

If you’ve worked with pastry for sourdough breakfast pockets or discard danishes, you already know that sealing matters. Lay a spoonful of filling in the center of one rectangle, brush the edges with egg wash, then place the second rectangle on top. Press gently around the edges, then use a fork to seal the border.

Once all your pop tarts are assembled, place them on a parchment-lined baking sheet and chill them again. This prevents spreading and helps the dough bake evenly.

Fillings that complement sourdough flavor

Filling is where you get to play. Fruit preserves work best because they hold their shape and provide a burst of sweetness. Strawberry, blueberry, and raspberry are popular, but don’t overlook unique flavors like fig, pear, or cherry vanilla. Use a thick jam to avoid leaks in the oven.

For something warm and nostalgic, try brown sugar and cinnamon. Mix it with a little flour and butter to create a filling similar to the swirl in sourdough cinnamon bread. It melts into a soft, caramel-like center.

Want a twist? Fill your tarts with lemon curd, Nutella, or even maple cream. The tang from the sourdough dough balances the sweetness beautifully. Before baking, use a fork to gently poke a few holes on top of each tart. This allows steam to escape, preventing too much puffing and keeping the shape crisp.

Baking, Glazing, and Storing Your Sourdough Pop Tarts

How to bake sourdough pop tarts to golden perfection

Once your sourdough pop tarts are chilled and sealed, it’s time to bake. Preheat your oven to 375°F. Arrange the tarts on a parchment-lined baking sheet with space between them for airflow. Brush the tops with an egg wash for a golden, glossy finish. This small step gives them a bakery-style look that feels professional and homemade all at once.

Bake for 22 to 28 minutes until the edges are golden brown and the tops have a light crust. If the filling bubbles out a little, that’s perfectly normal. Let them cool on the baking sheet for a few minutes before transferring to a rack. The texture will firm up as they rest.

This method works similarly to how I bake my sourdough discard herb biscuits, where a hot oven helps create a crisp outside while keeping the interior soft.

Glazing and storing for the week ahead

A simple glaze adds sweetness and makes your pop tarts look complete. You can whisk powdered sugar with milk and a splash of vanilla for a classic finish. Drizzle it while the tarts are still slightly warm so it sets with a light sheen. For fruit-filled tarts, try adding a little fruit juice to the glaze, like lemon or raspberry, for color and flavor.

If you’re using fillings like those in my baked sourdough discard donuts, the glaze can reflect those flavors. A cinnamon glaze works beautifully with brown sugar fillings, while a simple vanilla glaze pairs well with anything.

To store, keep the pop tarts in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days. For longer storage, freeze them flat on a tray, then transfer to a freezer bag. They reheat beautifully in a toaster or oven.

If you’re prepping ahead, these freeze-and-toast pastries are just as handy as anything boxed, but better in every way.

Troubleshooting, FAQs, and Final Thoughts

Avoiding common mistakes when making sourdough pop tarts

Even though this recipe is beginner-friendly, there are a few things that can trip up your bake. One of the biggest mistakes is using discard that’s too acidic or old. If your discard smells overly sharp or has separated too much, the dough may turn out too tangy or brittle. Use fresher discard from the past few days for a balanced flavor.

Another mistake is skipping the chill time. This dough needs rest in the fridge to firm up. If you try to roll it too soon, it will tear and stick. Chilling also prevents spreading in the oven and helps the layers flake.

Overfilling is another common issue. It’s tempting to pack your pop tarts with jam or filling, but too much causes leaks and sticky messes. A tablespoon is usually just right.

Lastly, be sure to seal the edges well. Press with a fork and brush the edges with egg wash before sealing. This tip, also used in my sourdough discard breakfast pockets, ensures the filling stays where it belongs.

FAQs

How do you get sourdough flavor in Pop-Tarts?
The sourdough flavor comes naturally from using discard in the dough. A longer fermentation adds more depth, but even a short rest gives that mild tang. Using discard from a recent feeding helps maintain a pleasant sour flavor without overpowering the sweet filling.

What Pop-Tart flavors were discontinued?
Some discontinued flavors include grape, frosted vanilla milkshake, and wild watermelon. While not available in stores anymore, you can recreate your favorites with homemade fillings. Try recreating these inside your sourdough pop tarts for a fun throwback.

Is sourdough discard healthier?
Sourdough discard still contains fermented benefits, including easier digestibility and better nutrient availability. While it’s not a health food on its own, using it in place of commercial doughs means fewer additives and more natural flavor.

What is the best flour to use for Pop-Tarts?
All-purpose flour works best for this dough. It gives the right balance of structure and tenderness. Avoid bread flour, which makes the dough too chewy. If you like a softer bite, try substituting a portion with pastry flour or using tips from my sourdough discard crescent rolls.

Final Thoughts

Sourdough pop tarts are more than a breakfast treat. They’re a fun, flaky way to turn discard into something exciting and nostalgic. With simple ingredients and creative fillings, these pastries bring homemade comfort to your kitchen table. Whether you enjoy them fresh, toasted, or frozen for later, they’re sure to become a favorite in your sourdough rotation.

You don’t need to be a pastry chef to master this recipe. Just a little patience, a chilled dough, and your favorite jam. Once you try them, you may never go back to the boxed kind again.

More recipes? Follow me: Facebook – Pinterest